In a world of soaring gas prices and overbearing advertisements, sometimes it’s nice to get into a car and forget about the world. No exhaust tone, no clunk when changing gears, no stopping to get gas. This idea of the perfect commuter car is exactly the niche the electric car fills, and no electric car does it like a Tesla. While its products are on the older side, the American automaker is still one of the gold standards in the range to price ratio. The Model S and Model X paved the way, but the more cost-conscious Model 3 and Model Y are now some of the most ubiquitous cars on the US roads. In fact, they are some of the most popular cars in the world, consistently sharing the top spots for most bought cars in the last five years.
UPDATE: 2026/05/30 11:13 EST BY DAN CLOUGHER
Depreciation Comparison: How The Two Models Compare
Information has been added on the used pricing of these two models, including where different grades sit after both three and five years on the market.
So with these both now being proven designs, with worldwide appeal, and a recent facelift, what is the perfect mainstream Tesla for you? Today, we will look at the differences between the Tesla Model 3 and Model Y, compare prices, and which might be perfect for you.
This on-paper comparison highlights what each of the models bring to the table. The base MSRP (manufacturer’s suggested retail price), where mentioned, excludes destination fees and other costs. Toyota reserves the right to change pricing without prior notice.
New Model 3 vs Model Y: Battle Of The Electric Titans
2026 Model 3
The Tesla Model 3 Performance. Fast, but also leaning towards the heavy side.Tesla
2026 Tesla Model 3 Specification
Standard RWD
Premium RWD
Premium AWD
Performance AWD
Price
$36,990
$42,490
$47,490
$54,990
Range (EPA)
321 miles
363 miles
346 miles
309 miles
0–60 Time
5.8 sec
4.9 sec
4.2 sec
2.9 sec
Charging Speed
170 miles in 15 minutes
195 miles in 15 minutes
185 miles in 15 minutes
162 miles in 15 minutes
Super Charging Max Speed
250 kW
The Model 3 is THE electric car. It was a cultural phenomenon when it came out, giving the regular buyer a Tesla to aim for. There isn’t much that can be said about the Model 3 that hasn’t been said before. It is a little older than the Model Y, having been launched in July 2017. It was a watershed moment for the electric car, and cemented the idea of electric propulsion for the masses as the first true mass market electric car that didn’t have any stigma or drawbacks, unlike earlier attempts like the Nissan Leaf. The Model 3 did suffer from some build-quality issues on its launch, but those have been largely addressed by now. The car was updated in 2020, to coincide with the launch of the Model Y. It got improved range and a better electrical system overall, along with some styling improvements. It was 2023 that saw the biggest change for the Model 3, getting a new styling update, better tech, and a 10% increase in range. This second deep refresh was nicknamed the Highland update, named after the internal code name for the refresh.
While it has lost a lot of ground due to weakened incentives and the introduction of the Model Y, the Model 3 is still one of the best in class, and even comes in a performance trim.
2026 Model Y
2026 Tesla Model Y StandardTesla
Standard RWD
Standard AWD
Premium RWD
Premium AWD
Performance AWD
Price
$39,990
$41,990
$44,990
$48,990
$57,490
Range (EPA)
321 miles
294 miles
357 miles
327 miles
306 miles
0–60 Time
6.8 sec
4.6 sec
5.4 sec
4.6 sec
3.3 sec
Charging Speed
160 miles in 15 minutes
152 miles in 15 minutes
182 miles in 15 minutes
169 miles in 15 minutes
144 miles in 15 minutes
Supercharging Max Speed
250 kW
Max Towing
3,500 lbs
If the Model 3 was the incredible debut album to the mainstream electric car market, then the Model Y is the follow-up with better sound production and a record deal. Launching in 2020, the Model Y shares 76% parts with the Model 3 but offers them in a higher-up seating arrangement and more headroom. It was the second best-selling car of 2025, and even with the weakening of the electric market in the US, it will continue to be a seriously good seller. The Model Y got its big refresh in 2025, codenamed the Juniper update. It brought a light bar treatment to the front and back, better range and critically retained a turn signal stalk.
The Model Y also came with a third row, which has come and gone as the car has aged. Early Model Ys got a third starting in 2021, but then losing it a few years later, and then gaining the third row back to fill the void left by the death of the Model X.
Related
Tesla Model Y Juniper Vs. Model Y: 10 Major Updates
Here are all the changes made to Tesla’s best-selling crossover.
Depreciation Comparison: How The Two Models Compare
Rear quarter shot of a 2021 Tesla Model YTesla
As covered, the Model 3 is slightly cheaper, which makes sense, as it resides in a smaller segment. However, depreciation can oftentimes turn the tables on matters like these. For our comparison, we’ll look at how values sit on three- and five-year-old examples, and see which of the two electrified titans retains its value the best.
According to data pinched from the CarBuzz Marketplace, a 2021 Model Y kicks off from around $24,800. That will net buyers a Standard Range RWD model, whereas shelling out $27,000 would secure a Long Range AWD model. Performance models command just an extra $1,000 on top of this. For a three-year-old example, so a 2023 model year, expect to pay around $30,000 for a Standard Range model — be that AWD or RWD — and $33,000 for a Long Range AWD, while once again, Performance models command another $1,000 on top of this.
Numbers for the Model 3 aren’t wildly different, which is about what we’d expect to see, given how close the MSRPs are for these two models. Again, starting with a 2021 example, prices begin around $22,400 for average-condition Standard Range examples, while Long Range grades typically attract an extra $2,000 or so. Performance models change hands for just shy of $27,000, on average — that’s just $1,000 less than the equivalent same-year Model Y.
As for the 2023 model year, entry-level RWD models sell for $24,600 on average, Long Range AWD models sit just under $30,000, and Performance grades sell for $33,000. Once again, that’s just $1,000 shy of the same-year Model Y Performance.
So, while the Model 3 remains cheapest, as time passes the difference in price drops to become practically negligible. For buyers spending $27,000 to $33,000, what’s an extra $1,000? Sure, there are still pros and cons that apply to each model, but from a strict value standpoint, the Model Y looks to be the better purchase from a used pricing standpoint, thanks to the effects of depreciation.
Performance Comparison: 2026 Model 3 vs 2026 Model Y
Tesla Model 3 and Tesla Model YCarBuzz/Tesla
Model 3 Performance
2026 Tesla Model 3 Performance Specs
Powertrain
Two electric motors
Horsepower
510 hp
Torque
547 lb-ft
0–60
2.9 seconds
Top Speed
163 mph
While they are similar cars in their design and parts, the Model 3 and Model Y do have a clear difference in market position and performance. The Model 3 Performance is definitely the best trim to have. It is a true sports car killer, with a low center of gravity and instant torque. It is great bang for the buck as well. For just under $55,000, you get neck-snapping performance, as well as enough practicality for a daily car. That is a tough thing to argue against.
Model Y Performance
2026 Tesla Model Y Performance Specs
Powertrain
Two electric motors
Horsepower
510 hp
Torque
547 lb-ft
0–60
3.3 seconds
Top Speed
155 mph
While it is not quite as extreme as the Model 3, the Model Y in its top spec is still a true beast. The idea of being in a genuinely spacious family car that can get to 60 mph in around three seconds is mental. Both the Model 3 and Model Y get choice upgrades over the regular cars with items such as aluminum pedals, carbon-fiber dashboard, new door trims and the Performance 4DU dual-motor system. It is all sent to all four wheels and gets to a top speed of 155 mph.
The Model 3 Performance is undoubtedly the more performance-orientated model of the two, and offers a great bang for the buck to boot. Something to consider when choosing between them.
Interior: The Same, But Different
Model 3 Interior
2025 Tesla Model 3 InteriorTesla
Tesla Model 3 Interior
Seating
5 Seater
Headroom in inches – Front | Rear
40.3 | 37.7
Legroom in inches – Front | Rear
42.7 | 34.5
Trunk/Cargo Space
21 + 3.1 ft³ frunk
The Model 3 interior got a minor update with the 2023 update but has largely been the same throughout the car’s life. It is a very stripped back and minimalist approach, with every element of the car being controlled through the center 15.4-inch screen. The two controversial parts of this interior have always been that even things like the speedometer are only shown on the center screen, and that there is no Apple CarPlay or Android Auto.
Dimensions are where these two cars differ the most, and with its smaller sedan body style, the Model 3 suffers in this regard, at least in terms of practicality. The Model 3 is definitely more for young singles or young couples with no kids, having a smaller interior, fewer seats and worse headroom than its crossover counterpart.
Model Y Interior
Overhead shot of the 2023-2024 Tesla Model Y InteriorTesla
Tesla Model Y Interior
Seating
5/7 Seater
Headroom in inches – Front | Rear | 3rd Row
41 | 39.4 | TBA
Legroom in inches – Front | Rear
41.8 | 40.5 | TBA
Trunk/Cargo Space
30.2–76.2 ft³
The Model Y is the preferred choice if you are going to have more than a few people in the car regularly. It shares the same infotainment system and general interior layout as the Model 3 but with its larger body and extra third row, is a much more practical offering. The Model Y currently offers a 16-inch central touchscreen, ventilated seats, and an 8-inch rear touchscreen for second-row passengers, panoramic glass roof, and ambient lighting. The Model Y does suffer from that teardrop design that lots of EVs like to follow and, because of this, the third row is a rather cramped affair, only really suitable for children or short journeys.
Related
Tesla Model Y Competitors You Might Prefer If You’re Buying In 2025
Tesla is now no longer the default choice for EV buyers, so what’s on the menu if you’re looking for an electric crossover?
Which One Should You Go For: Model 3 Or Model Y?
Both are great commuters and incredible value in range per dollar, so choosing between these siblings is going to be difficult. The best way to decide which is best for you is to look at your lifestyle. For the younger, single people or couples who don’t require the third row, the Model 3 is cheaper, better looking, and better driving. For enthusiasts, it will also be the car of choice, although cars like the Hyundai Ioniq 5 N may be more fun to drive.
If you have a family, or want a higher driving position, then the Model Y is a no-brainer. It costs a bit more than the Model 3, but it is a more recently refreshed car that is the second best-selling vehicle currently for sale in the world for a reason.
Sources: Tesla
